Answering a law problem question
Problem questions assess whether you can apply the law to a set of facts, not simply recall it. A clear structure keeps your reasoning visible to the examiner.
- Identify the issues. Read the facts carefully, twice, and list every legal issue they raise, including those that appear minor.
- State the law. For each issue, set out the relevant rule and the authority that supports it, whether a case or a statutory provision.
- Apply the law to the facts. Explain how the rule operates on these particular facts. This is where most marks are gained or lost.
- Reach a conclusion. Give a reasoned answer to each issue, and explain where the outcome is uncertain and why.
Always answer the question as set. If you are asked to advise a particular party, frame each conclusion as advice to that party.
